Welcome to this issue of "Cash Flow Chronicles", where we look beyond the glossy annual reports and dig into the real financial health of India Inc. In a landscape dominated by earnings hype and revenue figures, it’s time investors realize: Profits are not enough.
Companies can—and often do—manipulate earnings through accounting wizardry. P/E ratios and ROC numbers might look good on paper, but they don’t always reflect the cash reality. The real test lies in Cash Flow from Operations, Free Cash Flow, Operating Margins, and Return on Capital Employed—the hidden numbers that actually matter.
Let’s break it down.
👉 Cash Flow from Operations: The True Pulse of a Business
CFO reflects the cash generated from a company’s core operating activities, excluding investing and financing flows. It’s the best indicator of whether the business model is actually making money.
Why It Matters:
High net profits + weak CFO = red flag for manipulation or trouble in collection cycles.
Healthy CFO = business can run daily operations without taking on more debt.
Real-Life Example:
Infosys consistently aligns its CFO with net profits, signaling healthy operations.
Jet Airways, despite showing profits in the books, had a declining CFO before its collapse.
👉 Free Cash Flow: What’s Left After All the Bills Are Paid
FCF shows the cash left after capital expenditures (CapEx). It’s what's truly available to investors, lenders, or for reinvestment.
Formula 1:
FCF = CFO – CapEx
Formula 2 (From Lender’s Perspective):
FCF = PAT + Depreciation + Amortisation + Interest on Loans – CapEx – (+) Increase (Decrease) in Current Assets + (-) Increase (Decrease) in Current Liabilities
Why It Matters:
Positive FCF = ability to pay dividends, reduce debt, or expand sustainably.
Consistently negative FCF = possible financial strain or unsustainable growth.
Examples:
Hindustan Unilever shows consistent FCF and healthy dividend payouts.
Zomato, despite aggressive growth, struggles with negative FCF due to high cash burn.
👉 Return on Capital Employed: Efficiency Exposed
ROCE reveals how effectively a company uses its capital to generate returns. It cuts through the hype and tells whether shareholder capital is being put to good use.
Formula:
ROCE = EBIT / (Total Assets - Current Liabilities)
Why It Matters:
High ROCE = capital-efficient business.
Low ROCE = possible asset mismanagement, regardless of profit levels.
Examples:
TCS shows a stellar ROCE (>30%)—a model of capital discipline.
Suzlon Energy once posted strong sales, but weak ROCE exposed poor capital utilization.
👉 Operating Margins: The Core Profitability Check
Operating Margin tells you how much of every rupee in sales is left after operational expenses—but before interest and taxes.
Formula:
Operating Margin = (Operating Profit / Revenue) x 100
Why It Matters:
High margins = pricing power or operational efficiency.
Shrinking margins = competitive pressure or rising costs.
Examples:
Nestle India maintains solid margins due to brand strength.
SpiceJet suffers margin volatility due to fuel cost swings and price wars.
👉 The Bottom Line: Profits Are Just the Cover Story
When evaluating a company:
Use CFO to verify real earnings.
Check FCF to assess true cash availability.
Review ROCE to measure how efficiently capital is being deployed.
Analyze Operating Margins to understand business resilience.
Together, these metrics help you see beyond the smoke and mirrors—where financial health either shines or collapses.
👉 Disclaimer
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investing involves risk. Always conduct your own research or consult a financial advisor.
💬 Let’s Talk!
What’s your experience with using these metrics in your investment journey? Have you spotted a company that looked great on the surface but failed the cash flow or ROCE test?
Share your stories, ask your questions, and let’s learn from each other!
Share this post